Bosor b'Cholov - Yagdil 5783: An onion that was 50 cc was diced with a knife that has a 10 cc blade. The onion was put into soup. How much soup do you need to nullify the onion in the following 2 cases:
a) The knife was meat, the soup was milk
b) The knife was non-kosher, the soup was kosher

Question

An onion that was 50 cc was diced with a knife that has a 10 cc blade. The onion was put into soup. How much soup do you need to nullify the onion in the following 2 cases:
a) The knife was meat, the soup was milk
b) The knife was non-kosher, the soup was kosher

Rabbi Berel Bell · Accepted Answer

a) 60 times the blade (60 times 10 cc)
b) Rama: 60 times the onion (60 times 50 cc)
Because the onion was chanan.
Mechaber: 60 times the blade (60 times 10 cc)

Bosor b'Cholov - Yagdil 5783

An onion that was 50 cc was diced with a knife that has a 10 cc blade. The onion was put into soup. How much soup do you need to nullify the onion in the following 2 cases: a) The knife was meat, the soup was milk b) The knife was non-kosher, the soup was kosher

A) 60 times the blade (60 times 10 cc) b) Rama: 60 times the onion (60 times 50 cc) Because the onion was chanan. Mechaber: 60 times the blade (60 times 10 cc)

Author